Order Pies For Thanksgiving Through November 18

Call 845-986-1059 to place pie and bakery orders for November 21 pick-up.

Enjoy a Sweet Treat on the Farm

Warwick, New York’s friendliest neighborhood Ice Cream Stand and Bakery has been serving the community for nearly 30 years. Pennings Farm Market offers indulgent sweets in a variety of flavors that keep in line with the seasons.

Ice Cream Stand Hours

Fall/Winter
Sun, Mon, Tues, Wed: 11am – 8pm
Thurs, Fri, Sat: 11a, – 9pm
*Rainy and snow day service inside.

Ice Cream Stand

At Pennings Farm Market, the most prominent flavor in our ice cream just may be nostalgia! Our old fashioned soft serve custard and more than 24 flavors of old-school hard pack ice cream give kiddos from ages 1 to 99 a certain special down-home feeling of days-gone-by. Could be the barn that houses the ice-cream stand*, could be the barn yard buddies that run along the fence-line in hopes of a nibble or two of animal feed or could simply be the variety of flavors of yore, like chocolate, vanilla and strawberry with white lightening possibly being the most exotic flavor on the menu.

For those who are reluctant to limit themselves to ice cream alone, the menu options include sundaes and shakes that allow for the addition of one or a combo of many of the available candy, nut and fruit toppings. During peach season, an added burst of sweetness from our orchard-grown peaches set atop a cup of vanilla soft-serve or hard pack makes for one of summer’s most refreshing flavor combinations.

An assortment of locally grown fresh fruit toppings including strawberries and blueberries add a taste of summer to sundaes and shakes. Whether it’s a cup, a cone, a shake or a sundae that calls to you, we

Ice Cream and Bakery at Pennings Farm Market in Warwick NY
Ice Cream and Bakery at Pennings Farm Market in Warwick NY

Pie Flavors

• Apple • Strawberry Rhubarb • Dutch Apple • Very Berry
• Apple Brown Betty •  Peach • Apple Cranberry • Peach Blueberry
• Apple Raspberry • Pumpkin Pecan

Bakery

If you time your visit right to Pennings Farm Market, you’ll be greeted with the sweet smell of fresh baked pies, cookies, tea breads and the star of the farm, apple cider donuts, drifting into the market from the kitchen.

Our resident baker brings generations of recipes and baking finesse to the farm as a member of the Pennings family. Recipes have been passed down that maintain the farm-fresh taste found in the pies, muffins, tea breads, cookies and donuts that are baked on the farm daily.

Whether you’re feeding a sweet tooth craving of your own or want to make an impression on visitors or hosts during your next gathering, you can count on the seasonal varieties of baked goods from Pennings Farm Market.

Apple Cider Donuts

Behold the warm apple cider donut. A favorite throughout the seasons, these soft, sugary treats become a high-demand commodity around the farm come Fall.

Offered year round by the dozen and half dozen inside the farm market, the outside Donut Shack opens its doors every September to feed the mass exodus of apple pickers who line up by the hundreds to procure their own fresh-baked dozen.

The apple cider donut has taken the lead as a favorite taste of old-fashioned fun in the country for all guests at Pennings Farm.

Come Try Some Ice Cream and a Sweet Bakery Treat on the Farm.

Menu